New York Eateries: Gone But Not Forgotten

Nedick’s was the Starbucks of the 50’s. Orange drink, doughnuts and hot dogs with a signature mustard relish. They were everywhere, even in little hole-in-the-wall joints down in the subways. I confess I like the fresh-squeezed places better down there, with the machines that would cut and squeeze oranges automatically, but Nedick’s is a treasured memory also.


Nedick’s in Newark

Nedick’s at Macy’s (Found at The Paper Collector)

Then there was Prexy’s. A local concern with just a few outlets in and around New York, they made hamburgers that were to die for. Little is known about the recipe that made them so good, but I remember eating there a number of times. Oh, those prices.

Prexy’s Matchbook

Prexy’s Logo from a China Plate

Last but not least, there was the Horn and Hardart Automat




The Automat, 1942, by J. Baylor Roberts

For a kid in the 50’s, nothing was more fun than getting pie or drinks or that incredible macaroni and cheese at the Automat; you’d get your nickels at the booth from a nickel-thrower, ladies with rubber tips on their fingers who could fling out a dollar’s worth of nickels without blinking. I could stand there for hours watching the lazy susans rotate around when they were empty, only to reappear magically refilled with new offerings.

I scored a copy of this book which gives a fascinating history of the chain, including lots of recipes.

Now I’m hungry.

The Old Wolf has spoken.

8 responses to “New York Eateries: Gone But Not Forgotten

  1. Pingback: Nedicks Nickel, 1953 | Playing in the World Game

  2. Pingback: Times Square Breadlines | Playing in the World Game

  3. Pingback: Times Square Breadlines | Playing in the World Game | Hey Sweetheart, Get Me Rewrite!

  4. Pingback: The World’s 50 Best Restaurants (2013) | Playing in the World Game

  5. Pingback: Nighthawks: Art and Life. | Playing in the World Game

  6. Pingback: No Hamburger Tuesday. | Playing in the World Game

  7. Pingback: Post 164: From The Old Wolf: I would gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today and Creamy mushroom pasta with caramelized onions and spinach | savyatseventy

  8. A few years prior to to their demise, Horn and Hardart came out with TV ads.

    The tagline I will always remember;

    “You can’t eat atmosphere”!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s